The Apex Times
Above the Noise
Politics Wire
PoliticsTrump administration-backed SBA contest to award $1 million in business pitches judged in WashingtonThe Apex TimesPoliticsFTC lawsuit set to target Amazon advertising practices, report says, as company shares dropThe Apex TimesPoliticsWhite House executive order on renaming Lake Ontario as “Lake America” prompts Google Maps label change, outlet saysThe Apex TimesPoliticsAmericans for Paper Access criticizes SEC proposal to make electronic delivery the default for certain financial disclosuresThe Apex TimesPoliticsAbdul El-Sayed rejects questions about Hasan Piker ties after inviting him to campaign in Michigan, sparking online backlashThe Apex TimesPoliticsJudge orders National Guard shooting suspect to be force-fed after months-long refusal to eatThe Apex TimesPoliticsClinton Foundation job listings draw criticism over “intern” role language and “discretion” requirement, Fox News reportsThe Apex TimesPoliticsHakeem Jeffries to brief reporters Monday afternoon as House returns for key votes, including stopgap spendingThe Apex TimesPoliticsTrump criticizes communities resisting nearby datacenter projects, linking opposition to economic declineThe Apex TimesPoliticsFlorida grand jury report says DeSantis administration misused $10 million from Medicaid settlement, but did not refer chargesThe Apex TimesPoliticsFDA proposal would require notification when companies add new substances to food, PBS reportsThe Apex TimesPoliticsNorth Carolina Republican candidate Laurie Buckhout fined $2,500 and barred for three years over Kalshi bets, according to reportThe Apex TimesPoliticsTrump administration-backed SBA contest to award $1 million in business pitches judged in WashingtonThe Apex TimesPoliticsFTC lawsuit set to target Amazon advertising practices, report says, as company shares dropThe Apex TimesPoliticsWhite House executive order on renaming Lake Ontario as “Lake America” prompts Google Maps label change, outlet saysThe Apex TimesPoliticsAmericans for Paper Access criticizes SEC proposal to make electronic delivery the default for certain financial disclosuresThe Apex TimesPoliticsAbdul El-Sayed rejects questions about Hasan Piker ties after inviting him to campaign in Michigan, sparking online backlashThe Apex TimesPoliticsJudge orders National Guard shooting suspect to be force-fed after months-long refusal to eatThe Apex TimesPoliticsClinton Foundation job listings draw criticism over “intern” role language and “discretion” requirement, Fox News reportsThe Apex TimesPoliticsHakeem Jeffries to brief reporters Monday afternoon as House returns for key votes, including stopgap spendingThe Apex TimesPoliticsTrump criticizes communities resisting nearby datacenter projects, linking opposition to economic declineThe Apex TimesPoliticsFlorida grand jury report says DeSantis administration misused $10 million from Medicaid settlement, but did not refer chargesThe Apex TimesPoliticsFDA proposal would require notification when companies add new substances to food, PBS reportsThe Apex TimesPoliticsNorth Carolina Republican candidate Laurie Buckhout fined $2,500 and barred for three years over Kalshi bets, according to reportThe Apex TimesPoliticsTrump administration-backed SBA contest to award $1 million in business pitches judged in WashingtonThe Apex TimesPoliticsFTC lawsuit set to target Amazon advertising practices, report says, as company shares dropThe Apex TimesPoliticsWhite House executive order on renaming Lake Ontario as “Lake America” prompts Google Maps label change, outlet saysThe Apex TimesPoliticsAmericans for Paper Access criticizes SEC proposal to make electronic delivery the default for certain financial disclosuresThe Apex TimesPoliticsAbdul El-Sayed rejects questions about Hasan Piker ties after inviting him to campaign in Michigan, sparking online backlashThe Apex TimesPoliticsJudge orders National Guard shooting suspect to be force-fed after months-long refusal to eatThe Apex TimesPoliticsClinton Foundation job listings draw criticism over “intern” role language and “discretion” requirement, Fox News reportsThe Apex TimesPoliticsHakeem Jeffries to brief reporters Monday afternoon as House returns for key votes, including stopgap spendingThe Apex TimesPoliticsTrump criticizes communities resisting nearby datacenter projects, linking opposition to economic declineThe Apex TimesPoliticsFlorida grand jury report says DeSantis administration misused $10 million from Medicaid settlement, but did not refer chargesThe Apex TimesPoliticsFDA proposal would require notification when companies add new substances to food, PBS reportsThe Apex TimesPoliticsNorth Carolina Republican candidate Laurie Buckhout fined $2,500 and barred for three years over Kalshi bets, according to reportThe Apex TimesPoliticsTrump administration-backed SBA contest to award $1 million in business pitches judged in WashingtonThe Apex TimesPoliticsFTC lawsuit set to target Amazon advertising practices, report says, as company shares dropThe Apex TimesPoliticsWhite House executive order on renaming Lake Ontario as “Lake America” prompts Google Maps label change, outlet saysThe Apex TimesPoliticsAmericans for Paper Access criticizes SEC proposal to make electronic delivery the default for certain financial disclosuresThe Apex TimesPoliticsAbdul El-Sayed rejects questions about Hasan Piker ties after inviting him to campaign in Michigan, sparking online backlashThe Apex TimesPoliticsJudge orders National Guard shooting suspect to be force-fed after months-long refusal to eatThe Apex TimesPoliticsClinton Foundation job listings draw criticism over “intern” role language and “discretion” requirement, Fox News reportsThe Apex TimesPoliticsHakeem Jeffries to brief reporters Monday afternoon as House returns for key votes, including stopgap spendingThe Apex TimesPoliticsTrump criticizes communities resisting nearby datacenter projects, linking opposition to economic declineThe Apex TimesPoliticsFlorida grand jury report says DeSantis administration misused $10 million from Medicaid settlement, but did not refer chargesThe Apex TimesPoliticsFDA proposal would require notification when companies add new substances to food, PBS reportsThe Apex TimesPoliticsNorth Carolina Republican candidate Laurie Buckhout fined $2,500 and barred for three years over Kalshi bets, according to reportThe Apex Times
Back to front
Judge rejects Trump bid to fight New York conviction in federal court, denying another push tied to presidential immunity
The Apex Times

THE APEX TIMES

Politics/The Apex Times/Aug 28, 1:46 PM EDT

Judge rejects Trump bid to fight New York conviction in federal court, denying another push tied to presidential immunity

U.S. District Judge Alvin Hellerstein ruled on President Donald Trump’s latest effort to remove or otherwise challenge his New York criminal conviction outside of New York state proceedings, again citing the strategy of using presidential-immunity arguments in federal court.

By The Apex Times Newsroom3 min readAI-assisted Apex article

A federal judge has denied President Donald Trump’s latest attempt to litigate his New York criminal conviction in federal court, rejecting a move intended to invoke presidential-immunity arguments and to challenge charges tied to a 2016 hush-money payment, The Hill reported on Friday. U.S. District Judge Alvin Hellerstein ruled that Trump cannot use federal court as a substitute forum for the conviction dispute, according to the report.

The latest bid, as described by The Hill, continues a procedural strategy Trump has pursued in connection with the New York case. The approach centers on the idea that presidential immunity could apply in a way that would undermine, delay, or otherwise disrupt criminal proceedings or related efforts to enforce or maintain charges and convictions.

According to The Hill, the effort aimed to move Trump’s challenge out of New York’s state courts. Under the strategy, Trump’s legal team sought to make presidential-immunity arguments in federal court rather than rely on state-court avenues, the report said, characterizing the effort as an attempt to eliminate charges by referencing what the publication described as immunity and the original conduct at issue.

The Hill also linked Trump’s federal-court tactic to a specific factual thread from the New York prosecution: a 2016 hush-money payment. The report described the payment in connection with evidence and conduct that prosecutors alleged and that has figured in litigation around Trump’s conviction, including references to materials allegedly handled after the payment.

Hellerstein’s ruling is another step in a broader set of post-conviction fights about venue and the scope of any presidential-immunity protections during a time when Trump is serving as President. While the report focuses on the procedural question of forum and removal attempts, it also underscores that Trump’s options appear constrained when federal judges decline to entertain federal-court collateral efforts.

The practical effect of the denial, as framed by the reporting, is to keep Trump’s conviction-related dispute anchored in the state-court process rather than allowing the dispute to proceed in federal court through the removal-or-challenge route Trump sought. That matters for timing because procedural litigation over venue and immunity can affect what stays in place, what can be argued, and how quickly parties can move to merits and subsequent review.

The decision also leaves open continued legal activity in the state system and in whatever limited federal avenues remain available after a court rejects removal. The Hill’s report indicated the ruling was issued Friday and described it as part of a series of Trump efforts to shift the fight into federal court.

A spokesperson for the parties was not included in the provided excerpt, and The Hill did not describe in the summary the full scope of the judge’s reasoning. Still, by denying the bid, the court effectively rejected the premise that Trump could use federal court to restart or reframe the conviction dispute through the immunity-oriented strategy presented in the filing, according to the report.

Why It Matters

  • The ruling affects venue, which can shape the timing and mechanics of how courts handle post-conviction claims tied to constitutional arguments like presidential immunity.
  • By rejecting the removal-style effort described by the report, the decision narrows Trump’s ability to repackage the New York conviction dispute in federal court in the manner his filings sought.
  • The decision highlights the continuing procedural friction between federal and state courts when a sitting President raises immunity-related claims connected to state criminal proceedings.
  • Keeping the dispute in state proceedings means the next steps will likely depend on state-court litigation and whatever federal review is available after venue and immunity arguments have been adjudicated in the specific manner attempted.

Sources

Key Facts

  • U.S. District Judge Alvin Hellerstein denied President Donald Trump’s latest bid to challenge his New York criminal conviction outside of New York state court, The Hill reported on Friday.
  • The effort sought to move the dispute to federal court and relied on a strategy tied to presidential-immunity arguments.
  • The Hill linked the filings to charges connected to a 2016 hush-money payment at the center of the New York case.
  • The ruling means Trump’s conviction-related litigation would remain in the state-court track rather than proceeding through the federal-court removal approach described by The Hill.
  • The Hill reported the denial as another attempt to use federal court to challenge charges or the conviction by invoking immunity.