THE APEX TIMES
Trump lawyer threatens $5 billion lawsuit over National Guard effectiveness report from Center for American Progress
President Donald Trump’s attorney sent a letter demanding a retraction of a Center for American Progress report that argues the president’s National Guard deployment strategy did not measurably reduce crime, according to a report published Friday.
President Donald Trump’s lawyer threatened to file a $5 billion lawsuit unless the Center for American Progress retracts a report criticizing the effectiveness of Trump’s National Guard deployment approach, The Guardian reported on Aug. 21, citing the think tank’s account of receiving the letter.
The letter, described by the think tank, targets a Center for American Progress report that argued the deployment of the National Guard failed to show a measurable impact on crime. In its account, the organization said the report also raised questions about the costs associated with the deployments, asserting they cost billions of dollars.
According to The Guardian’s reporting, the dispute centers on whether the think tank’s findings are accurate and whether they should be revised or retracted. The letter’s demand is framed as an effort to address the report’s conclusions about crime outcomes and the value of the policy.
The Guardian said the report was released earlier in August and that the think tank received the lawyer’s letter after the report went public. The publication did not provide a copy of the letter or any court filing in its report, and it did not specify a deadline for retraction beyond the demand described by the think tank.
The Center for American Progress is a left-leaning policy organization and the report is presented by the group as research-based analysis of outcomes tied to the president’s National Guard rollout. The Guardian’s story does not identify additional agencies or specific federal programs by name, but it characterizes the overall deployment effort as something the report evaluated in terms of public safety results.
Trump’s attorney’s alleged threat of a multibillion-dollar lawsuit adds a high-stakes legal dimension to a policy debate that has been shaped by crime and enforcement concerns tied to federal support for local policing through National Guard deployments, according to the Guardian’s account.
It was not immediately clear from the report whether the threatened action would be filed in state or federal court, what specific legal claims the letter would pursue, or what remedy would be sought if a retraction is not issued. The Guardian’s reporting also did not confirm whether the think tank has agreed to retract or to respond through additional edits, public statements, or formal legal process.
For now, the dispute appears to turn on the interaction between research publications, accuracy challenges, and potential legal exposure tied to how policy effectiveness is described. The next step, if any lawsuit is filed, would likely depend on whether the think tank retracts or substantially revises the contested conclusions or whether the demand escalates into litigation.
Why It Matters
- If filed, a lawsuit would test how disputes over policy research and contested findings are handled through civil litigation, including the procedural timelines that follow a retraction demand.
- The allegation centers on whether National Guard deployment outcomes can be supported by measurable crime impacts, which can affect how federal resources are justified and discussed publicly.
- The cost framing described by the think tank underscores how public safety policy is increasingly evaluated not only by stated goals but also by economic and results-based metrics.
- The dispute also highlights due process and First Amendment-adjacent concerns that can arise when governments or senior officials challenge research-based publications through legal threats.
- The immediate practical effect depends on whether the Center for American Progress retracts or revises its report and whether the threat escalates into a court case.
Sources
Key Facts
- The Guardian reported that President Donald Trump’s lawyer sent a letter to the Center for American Progress threatening a $5 billion lawsuit unless the organization retracts a report.
- The report at issue, as described by The Guardian, argued the National Guard deployment approach associated with the Trump administration did not show a measurable impact on crime.
- The Guardian reported that the think tank’s report raised questions about the cost of the National Guard deployments, describing them as costing billions of dollars.
- The Guardian reported that the think tank said it received the lawyer’s letter after the report’s release, but it did not include the letter text or any court filing in its account.
- The Guardian’s report did not specify a lawsuit filing venue, deadline for retraction, or the precise legal claims contemplated in the threat.